Ch 15: PEER REVIEW AND QUALITY REVIEW — Comprehensive ICSI Professional Test Series
CS Professional
📚 Compliance Management, Audit & Due Diligence
📖 Ch.15 — PEER REVIEW AND QUALITY REVIEW
⚖️ V3: Case Law & Landmark Precedents
⚡ Free Mode (Answers Locked)
⏱ Duration: 54 Mins
🎯 Total Marks: 30
Passed at: 12 Marks
Max Attempts: 10
⚖️ Statutory Applicability: Applicable for ICSI CS Professional Examinations (2022 Syllabus - Latest Applicable Provisions)
Answer ALL questions. Draft operative clauses, provide step-by-step arithmetic working notes, or deconstruct statutory provisions and landmark precedents as required.
📑 Exam Questions
3 Questions • Total 30 MarksQuestion 1: ICSI Peer Review Guidelines: Scope, Peer Reviewer Qualification, Periodicity, and Mandatory Peer Review for Listed Audits
10 Marks
📌 Latest ICSI CS Professional Syllabus Standard for PEER REVIEW AND QUALITY REVIEW
Kaveri Secretarial Services LLP, a practicing company secretary firm, has been appointed to conduct the secretarial audit of Bharat Chemicals Limited, a top-100 listed entity by market capitalization. The firm's managing partner, CS Ramachandran, who holds a valid peer review certificate issued 2 years ago, is designated as the lead auditor. However, during the ongoing SEBI compliance review, a question arises regarding the mandatory periodicity of peer review under the ICSI Peer Review Guidelines, the specific qualifications required for undertaking audits of top listed entities, and the scope of attestation services covered. Examine the legal validity of CS Ramachandran's eligibility and detail the compliance obligations, periodicity mandates, and procedural steps required for renewing and maintaining the Peer Review Certificate under the ICSI Peer Review Guidelines.
🔒 Official Model Solution
Model answers and self-evaluation solutions are available in the Premium Tier & Rankers Plan.
Question 2: Peer Review Process: Desk Review, On-Site Visit, Sample Selection of Working Papers, and Peer Review Certificate
10 Marks
📌 Latest ICSI CS Professional Syllabus Standard for PEER REVIEW AND QUALITY REVIEW
M/s Deshmukh & Associates, a practicing company secretary firm auditing Kaveri Logistics Ltd., underwent a Peer Review mandated by the ICSI Peer Review Board. During the on-site visit, the Peer Reviewer demanded working papers concerning secretarial audits of related-party transactions (RPTs) executed under Section 188 of the Companies Act, 2013. The firm declined access, citing client confidentiality obligations under Section 129 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, and professional ethics. Concurrently, the Peer Review Board withheld the Peer Review Certificate (PRC) pending this compliance. Meera Deshmukh, managing partner, challenges the board's authority, arguing that desk review findings were satisfactory and on-site demands breach privilege. Evaluate the legal validity of the firm's refusal and the Peer Review Board's withholding of the PRC, referencing the Guidelines for Peer Review of Attest Services by Company Secretaries.
🔒 Official Model Solution
Model answers and self-evaluation solutions are available in the Premium Tier & Rankers Plan.
Question 3: Quality Review Board (QRB) of ICSI: Structure, Review of Secretarial Audit Quality, and Recommendations
10 Marks
📌 Latest ICSI CS Professional Syllabus Standard for PEER REVIEW AND QUALITY REVIEW
Kaveri Logistics Ltd., a listed entity, recently underwent a Quality Review Board (QRB) evaluation under the Company Secretaries Act, 1980, concerning the Secretarial Audit Report issued by CS Meera Deshmukh. The QRB review report highlighted critical deficiencies, including failure to appropriately verify material non-compliances under SEBI (Listing Obligations and Disclosure Requirements) Regulations, 2015, and inadequate working paper documentation supporting the compliance opinion. CS Meera Deshmukh contends that the QRB lacks jurisdiction to evaluate subjective professional judgments and that her working papers are protected under client confidentiality. Examine the powers and structure of the QRB of ICSI, the scope of review of secretarial audit quality, and advise CS Meera Deshmukh on the legal validity of her contentions under the Company Secretaries Act, 1980 and relevant guidelines.
🔒 Official Model Solution
Model answers and self-evaluation solutions are available in the Premium Tier & Rankers Plan.
Advertisement