Ch 2: EVALUATION OF RISKY PROPOSALS FOR INVESTMENT DECISIONS — V3: 70% Practical Problems & 30% Theory / Standards Rationale
Final
📚 Strategic Financial Management
📖 Ch.2 — EVALUATION OF RISKY PROPOSALS FOR INVESTMENT DECISIONS
⚖️ V3: Case Law & Landmark Precedents
⚡ Free Mode (Answers Locked)
⏱ Duration: 90 Mins
🎯 Total Marks: 50
Passed at: 20 Marks
Max Attempts: 10
⚖️ Statutory Applicability: Applicable for ICMAI CMA Final Examinations (December 2026 Attempt - Syllabus 2022)
Exhaustive ICMAI CMA Final Test Series with Step-by-Step Computational Schedules, Case Studies, and Statutory Compliance Tables.
📑 Exam Questions
5 Questions • Total 50 MarksQuestion 1: PRACTICAL COMPUTATION: Advanced multi-scenario on EVALUATION OF RISKY PROPOSALS FOR INVESTMENT DECISIONS (Part 1)
10 Marks
📌 Integration of Finance Act tax rates, surcharge, cess, Ind AS 16, and CAS 4 standards.
Kalinga Steels & Alloys Ltd is evaluating two mutually exclusive capital investment proposals for expanding its specialized alloy production line: Project 'Aarav' (High Automation) and Project 'Bhavik' (Semi-Automation). Both projects require an initial capital outlay of INR 5,00,00,000 at Year 0. The economic life of both projects is 4 years, with a zero salvage value at the end of Year 4. The company's risk-free rate is 7.00% per annum, and the market risk premium is 6.50%. The corporate tax rate is 25.00% plus a 10% surcharge on income tax and 4% health & education cess. Due to macroeconomic volatility, the management has mapped three distinct economic scenarios: Optimistic, Normal, and Pessimistic. The estimated annual cash inflows before depreciation and tax (CFBDT) along with their respective subjective probability distributions and systematic risk metrics (Beta) for both projects are detailed in the data table below:
| Economic Scenario | Probability | Project 'Aarav' CFBDT (INR) | Project 'Aarav' Beta (eta) | Project 'Bhavik' CFBDT (INR) | Project 'Bhavik' Beta (eta) |
| :--- | :--- | :--- | :--- | :--- | :--- |
| Optimistic | 0.30 | 2,50,00,000 | 1.45 | 2,10,00,000 | 1.10 |
| Normal | 0.50 | 1,80,00,000 | 1.25 | 1,60,00,000 | 0.95 |
| Pessimistic | 0.20 | 1,10,00,000 | 1.05 | 1,00,00,000 | 0.80 |
Additional Information:
1. Depreciation is charged on a Straight-Line Method (SLM) for tax and accounting purposes.
2. The cost of capital is determined using the Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM) for each scenario, where k_e = R_f + β × (R_m - R_f). The overall weighted discount rate for each project must be computed using scenario probabilities.
3. The company follows Cost Accounting Standard (CAS 4) on Cost of Production for captive consumption valuation and CAS 11 on Interest and Financing Charges, alongside Ind AS 16 (Property, Plant and Equipment) and Ind AS 36 (Impairment of Assets).
You are required as the Chief Senior Examiner to present an exhaustive 10-mark evaluation comprising:
(a) Detailed computation of expected net cash flows, certainty equivalent or risk-adjusted discount rates, and Expected Net Present Value (ENPV) for both projects.
(b) Comprehensive Working Notes demonstrating arithmetic steps for tax shields, depreciation, risk-adjusted hurdle rates, and present value factors.
(c) A rigorous theoretical rationale citing applicable Ind AS, Cost Accounting Standards (CAS), and Income-tax Act provisions governing capital budgeting, risk discounting, and depreciation.
🔒 Official Model Solution
Model answers and self-evaluation solutions are available in the Premium Tier & Rankers Plan.
Question 2: PRACTICAL COMPUTATION: Advanced multi-scenario on EVALUATION OF RISKY PROPOSALS FOR INVESTMENT DECISIONS (Part 2)
10 Marks
📌 Application of Ind AS 36, Ind AS 113, CAS 17, and Income-tax Act Section 32 for risk-adjusted capital budgeting.
Vardhaman Synthetics Ltd is evaluating a high-tech specialized polymer manufacturing plant. The project involves an initial capital outlay of INR 500 Lakhs at Year 0. The plant has an economic life of 4 years with no salvage value. Depreciation is to be charged on a Straight-Line Basis for accounting purposes, but the company uses the Written Down Value (WDV) method at 15% for income tax purposes under the Income-tax Act, 1961. The corporate tax rate is 25% plus a 10% surcharge and 4% health & education cess (Effective Tax Rate = 27.82%). Due to extreme volatility in global crude oil feedstock pricing and foreign exchange fluctuations, management has projected three economic scenarios for operating cash flows (exclusive of depreciation and tax) over the 4-year horizon as presented in the data table below. The risk-free rate is 7%, the market risk premium is 6%, and the equity beta of the project is estimated at 1.25. The company maintains a target capital structure consisting of 60% equity and 40% debt, with a pre-tax cost of debt of 10%. Required: (a) Compute the certainty equivalent cash flows and net present value (NPV) under each scenario using the Certainty Equivalent (CE) approach and the Risk-Adjusted Discount Rate (RADR) approach. Compare the decision outcomes. (b) Provide an exhaustive evaluation of the statutory framework, citing relevant Ind AS, Cost Accounting Standards (CAS), and Income-tax Act provisions governing capital budgeting, asset impairment, and cash flow recognition.
| Economic Scenario | Probability | Year 1 CFAT (INR Lakhs) | Year 2 CFAT (INR Lakhs) | Year 3 CFAT (INR Lakhs) | Year 4 CFAT (INR Lakhs) | Certainty Equivalent Factor (CEF) ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Optimistic | 0.30 | 190 | 220 | 250 | 280 | 0.90 ||
| Most Likely | 0.50 | 140 | 160 | 180 | 200 | 0.75 ||
| Pessimistic | 0.20 | 90 | 100 | 110 | 120 | 0.60 |
🔒 Official Model Solution
Model answers and self-evaluation solutions are available in the Premium Tier & Rankers Plan.
Question 3: PRACTICAL COMPUTATION: Advanced multi-scenario on EVALUATION OF RISKY PROPOSALS FOR INVESTMENT DECISIONS (Part 3)
10 Marks
📌 Applicable Ind AS 16, Income Tax Act Section 32, CAPM Discounting, and CAS standards.
Kalinga Steels & Alloys Ltd is evaluating an advanced, automated precision rolling mill line requiring an initial capital outlay of INR 5,000 Lakhs. The project life is 4 years with no salvage value. Due to market volatility, the company employs a multi-scenario probabilistic approach to evaluate risky proposals for investment decisions under capital budgeting. The cash flows are subject to technological and demand shocks. The probability distribution of annual net cash inflows (before depreciation and tax, uniform across years 1 to 4) is estimated under three distinct economic scenarios: Optimistic, Most Likely, and Pessimistic, with probabilities of 0.25, 0.50, and 0.25 respectively. The initial outlay attracts 100% depreciation under Income Tax Act, 1961 provisions for energy-saving / pollution control equipment in Year 1, while for financial reporting under Ind AS 16, straight-line depreciation over 4 years is adopted. Corporate tax rate is 25% plus surcharge and cess effective at 34.944%. The company's risk-free rate is 7.5%, market risk premium is 6.5%, and project beta is 1.40. Required: (a) Compute the Expected Net Present Value (ENPV) and Standard Deviation of NPV under the probabilistic multi-scenario approach. (b) Formulate the financial decision incorporating Ind AS 16 and Income Tax Act Section 32 depreciation shields, Cost Accounting Standards (CAS-4) valuation principles for internal transfers, and Strategic Financial Management standards.
🔒 Official Model Solution
Model answers and self-evaluation solutions are available in the Premium Tier & Rankers Plan.
Question 4: PRACTICAL COMPUTATION: Advanced multi-scenario on EVALUATION OF RISKY PROPOSALS FOR INVESTMENT DECISIONS (Part 4)
10 Marks
📌 Evaluated in accordance with Ind AS 36, Cost Accounting Standards (CAS 7), and Companies Act 2013 risk governance frameworks.
Vindhya Petrochemicals Ltd is evaluating a high-tech specialized polymer manufacturing plant requiring a total initial capital outlay of INR 500 Lakhs at the beginning of Year 0. The plant has an economic life of 4 years with no salvage value. Due to severe economic volatility, the company's financial planning team has formulated three discrete probabilistic economic scenarios (Boom, Normal, Recession) with distinct cash flow streams and respective probabilities. The company's risk-free rate is 7.5%, the market risk premium is 6.0%, and the equity beta of the project is estimated at 1.25. Depreciation is charged on a straight-line basis for tax purposes, and the corporate income tax rate is 25%.
Table 1: Scenario Probabilities and Annual Cash Flows (INR in Lakhs)
| Scenario | Probability (P) | Year 1 Cash Inflow | Year 2 Cash Inflow | Year 3 Cash Inflow | Year 4 Cash Inflow |
| :--- | :---: | :---: | :---: | :---: | :---: |
| Boom | 0.30 | 180.00 | 210.00 | 250.00 | 300.00 |
| Normal | 0.50 | 120.00 | 140.00 | 160.00 | 180.00 |
| Recession | 0.20 | 60.00 | 70.00 | 80.00 | 90.00 |
Required:
(a) Compute the Project's Risk-Adjusted Discount Rate (WACC / Hurdle Rate) using the Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM).
(b) Prepare an exhaustive Statement of Expected Net Present Value (ENPV), calculate the Coefficient of Variation (CV) of the project's NPV, and evaluate the project's risk using decision tree logic and certainty equivalent approaches under Ind AS 36 / Cost Accounting Standards.
(c) Provide the comprehensive statutory, financial, and cost accounting rationale under the Companies Act 2013, Cost Accounting Standards (CAS), and Income Tax Act 1961.
🔒 Official Model Solution
Model answers and self-evaluation solutions are available in the Premium Tier & Rankers Plan.
Question 5: PRACTICAL COMPUTATION: Advanced multi-scenario on EVALUATION OF RISKY PROPOSALS FOR INVESTMENT DECISIONS (Part 5)
10 Marks
📌 Evaluated in accordance with Ind AS 36, CAS-17, and Income-tax Act 1961 provisions.
Kalinga Steels & Alloys Ltd is evaluating a high-risk expansion project for manufacturing specialized aerospace-grade titanium components. The initial capital outlay required at t = 0 is INR 500 Lakhs, inclusive of machinery, factory building modifications, and working capital margin. The economic life of the project is 4 years. Due to extreme market volatility in defense and aerospace raw material costs, the Chief Financial Officer decides to evaluate the project under three probability-assigned economic scenarios: Optimistic, Normal, and Pessimistic.
Additional Data Provided:
| Particulars | Optimistic Scenario | Normal Scenario | Pessimistic Scenario |
| :--- | :--- | :--- | :--- |
| Probability (P_i) | 0.25 | 0.50 | 0.25 |
| Annual Cash Inflows (Years 1-4) | INR 220 Lakhs | INR 160 Lakhs | INR 95 Lakhs |
| Salvage Value at end of Year 4 | INR 50 Lakhs | INR 30 Lakhs | INR 10 Lakhs |
The firm's risk-free rate of return is 8.00% per annum. The systematic risk premium for this risk class is 7.50% with an equity beta of 1.40. The company's target capital structure comprises 60% Equity and 40% Debt. The pre-tax cost of debt is 11.00%, and the applicable corporate income tax rate is 25.00%.
Required:
(a) Compute the Risk-Adjusted Discount Rate (RADR) using the Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM) framework and the Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC).
(b) Prepare an exhaustive Statement of Expected Net Present Value (ENPV), Standard Deviation of NPV, and Coefficient of Variation to evaluate the project's total risk.
(c) Provide an authoritative technical evaluation covering Cost Accounting Standards (CAS), Ind AS 36 (Impairment of Assets), and Income-tax Act 1961 provisions regarding capital budgeting decisions.
🔒 Official Model Solution
Model answers and self-evaluation solutions are available in the Premium Tier & Rankers Plan.
Advertisement