Ch 9: ACCOUNTS AND AUDITORS — V3: Challenger Twisted Scenarios & Dec 2026 Amendments
CS Executive
📚 Company Law & Practice
📖 Ch.9 — ACCOUNTS AND AUDITORS
⚖️ V3: Case Law & Landmark Precedents
⚡ Free Mode (Answers Locked)
⏱ Duration: 90 Mins
🎯 Total Marks: 50
Passed at: 20 Marks
Max Attempts: 10
⚖️ Statutory Applicability: Applicable for ICSI CS Executive Examinations (December 2026 Attempt - Syllabus 2022)
Exhaustive ICSI CS Executive Test Series with 4-Tier Rubrics, Statutory Analysis, and Real-world Corporate Problem Scenarios.
📑 Exam Questions
5 Questions • Total 50 MarksQuestion 1: Common Partner Network Rotation Circumvention Trap
10 Marks
📌 Based on Section 139(2) and Rule 6(3) of the Companies (Audit and Auditors) Rules, 2014.
M/s. Sahyadri Ltd., a listed company, has completed the tenure of its statutory auditor, 'Alpha & Co.', after 10 consecutive years. Upon the expiry of the term, the Board of Directors proposes to appoint 'Beta & Associates' as the new auditor. It is observed that two equity partners of 'Alpha & Co.' are also equity partners in 'Beta & Associates'. Furthermore, both firms operate under the same 'Network' brand name and share common resources. Examine the validity of this appointment under the Companies Act, 2013, and the Companies (Audit and Auditors) Rules, 2014, specifically addressing the 'Common Partner' and 'Network' circumvention traps.
🔒 Official Model Solution
Model answers and self-evaluation solutions are available in the Premium Tier & Rankers Plan.
Question 2: NFRA vs ICAI Disciplinary Supremacy Conflict
10 Marks
📌 Reference to the 2023 Delhi High Court judgment on NFRA jurisdiction.
A Chartered Accountant (CA), acting as a statutory auditor for a listed company, has been issued a debarment order by the National Financial Reporting Authority (NFRA) for professional misconduct under Section 132(4) of the Companies Act, 2013. The CA challenges this order before the High Court, contending that the NFRA lacks the constitutional authority to penalize individual members, asserting that the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI) holds exclusive disciplinary jurisdiction over its members under the Chartered Accountants Act, 1949. Critically analyze the validity of the CA’s contention in light of the non-obstante clause in Section 132 and relevant judicial precedents.
🔒 Official Model Solution
Model answers and self-evaluation solutions are available in the Premium Tier & Rankers Plan.
Question 3: Prohibited Non-Audit Services under Section 144 Provided via Associate
10 Marks
📌 None, consistent with the Companies Act 2013 framework.
M/s. Alpha & Co., a firm of Chartered Accountants, is the statutory auditor of Sahyadri Tech Ltd. Sahyadri Tech Ltd. has engaged 'Beta Consulting Services', a firm where the partners of Alpha & Co. hold a 60% interest, to provide outsourced book-keeping and actuarial services. The management of Sahyadri Tech Ltd. contends that since Section 144 of the Companies Act, 2013 applies only to the 'auditor' and not to their associate entities, the arrangement is legally permissible. Examine the validity of this contention in light of the Companies Act, 2013 and the Companies (Audit and Auditors) Rules, 2014.
🔒 Official Model Solution
Model answers and self-evaluation solutions are available in the Premium Tier & Rankers Plan.
Question 4: NCLT Section 140(5) Suo Motu Removal for Auditor-Promoter Collusion
10 Marks
📌 The second proviso to Section 140(5) is the core focus, reinforced by the 2023 Supreme Court ruling in Deloitte Haskins.
The Central Government, acting through the Regional Director, filed a petition before the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) under Section 140(5) of the Companies Act, 2013, alleging that M/s. Alpha & Associates, the statutory auditors of Sahyadri Infrastructure Ltd., colluded with the promoters to siphon off funds through fictitious transactions. Upon receiving notice of the petition, the auditor immediately tendered their resignation to the Board of Directors, claiming that the NCLT loses jurisdiction over them once they cease to be the auditor. Discuss the legal validity of this contention in light of the second proviso to Section 140(5) and relevant judicial precedents.
🔒 Official Model Solution
Model answers and self-evaluation solutions are available in the Premium Tier & Rankers Plan.
Question 5: CARO 2020 Whistleblower Clause Omission vs Secretarial Standards
10 Marks
📌 CARO 2020 is mandatory for all audits starting from FY 2021-22.
M/s. Sahyadri Dynamics Ltd. is a listed entity. During the audit for the financial year 2023-24, the Statutory Auditor received multiple formal whistleblower complaints via the company’s vigil mechanism regarding undisclosed related party billing and potential diversion of funds. Despite these complaints, the Auditor omitted any mention of these findings in the CARO 2020 report under clause (xi)(e), relying solely on a written management assurance that the transactions were 'in the ordinary course of business' and 'at arm's length'. As a Company Secretary, analyze the professional negligence of the auditor, the implications under Section 143 of the Companies Act, 2013, and the conflict between management assurance and the auditor's independent duty to report fraud.
🔒 Official Model Solution
Model answers and self-evaluation solutions are available in the Premium Tier & Rankers Plan.
Advertisement