Ch 2: EVALUATION OF RISKY PROPOSALS FOR INVESTMENT DECISIONS — V2: Applied Practical Scenarios & Corporate Computations
Final
📚 Strategic Financial Management
📖 Ch.2 — EVALUATION OF RISKY PROPOSALS FOR INVESTMENT DECISIONS
📘 V2: Study Material & Test Yourself
⚡ Free Mode (Answers Locked)
⏱ Duration: 90 Mins
🎯 Total Marks: 50
Passed at: 20 Marks
Max Attempts: 10
⚖️ Statutory Applicability: Applicable for ICMAI CMA Final Examinations (December 2026 Attempt - Syllabus 2022)
Exhaustive ICMAI CMA Final Test Series with Step-by-Step Computational Schedules, Case Studies, and Statutory Compliance Tables.
📑 Exam Questions
5 Questions • Total 50 MarksQuestion 1: PRACTICAL COMPUTATION: Advanced multi-scenario on EVALUATION OF RISKY PROPOSALS FOR INVESTMENT DECISIONS (Part 1)
10 Marks
📌 Evaluated in accordance with Ind AS 36, Ind AS 113, and Income-tax Act 1961 provisions governing depreciation tax shields.
Vindhya Petrochemicals Ltd is evaluating a high-risk strategic capacity expansion proposal involving a capital outlay of Rs. 1,200 Lakhs for specialized polymer production. The project has a useful economic life of 4 years with no salvage value. The firm follows straight-line depreciation for tax purposes. To incorporate risk into the capital budgeting process, the Chief Financial Officer has provided the following probability distributions of annual cash flows before tax (CFBT) and three distinct economic scenarios for the project's life. The corporate tax rate is 25% (plus applicable surcharge/cess assumed flat at 25% net effective), and the company's risk-free rate of return is 8%. The risk-adjusted discount rate (RADR) is determined based on a base cost of capital of 12% plus a project risk premium of 4%, resulting in a hurdle rate of 16%. In addition, the firm wishes to evaluate certainty equivalent coefficients (CEC) as an alternative risk mitigation technique. The relevant financial data across three economic scenarios (Optimistic, Most Likely, Pessimistic) are detailed in the table below:
| Economic Scenario | Annual Cash Flow Before Tax (CFBT - Rs. Lakhs) | Probability (P) | Certainty Equivalent Coefficient (CEC) | Expected Life (Years) |
| :--- | :--- | :--- | :--- | :--- |
| Optimistic | 550.00 | 0.25 | 0.90 | 4 |
| Most Likely | 400.00 | 0.55 | 0.75 | 4 |
| Pessimistic | 220.00 | 0.20 | 0.50 | 4 |
Additional Data:
- Initial Cash Outlay (Year 0): Rs. 1,200 Lakhs
- Salvage Value: Nil
- Depreciation Method: Straight Line Method (SLM) for tax purposes (Rs. 1,200 Lakhs / 4 Years = Rs. 300 Lakhs per annum)
- Corporate Income Tax Rate: 25%
- Risk-Free Rate (Rf): 8%
- Risk-Adjusted Discount Rate (RADR): 16%
You are required to compute:
1. The Expected Net Present Value (ENPV) using the Risk-Adjusted Discount Rate (RADR) method.
2. The Certainty Equivalent Net Present Value (CENPV) method.
3. A comparative risk-return evaluation and strategic recommendation for Vindhya Petrochemicals Ltd in compliance with strategic financial management principles.
🔒 Official Model Solution
Model answers and self-evaluation solutions are available in the Premium Tier & Rankers Plan.
Question 2: PRACTICAL COMPUTATION: Advanced multi-scenario on EVALUATION OF RISKY PROPOSALS FOR INVESTMENT DECISIONS (Part 2)
10 Marks
📌 Compliant with Companies Act 2013, CAS 7, CAS 15, and Ind AS 116 regarding lease and capital asset valuations.
Kalinga Steels & Alloys Ltd is evaluating two mutually exclusive, high-risk capital expenditure projects for its new specialized alloy manufacturing facility in Odisha, namely Project 'Utkal' and Project 'Hirakud'. Both projects require an initial capital outlay of INR 500,00udd at t=0. The company applies a risk-adjusted discount rate methodology combined with probabilistic cash flow distribution under three economic states: Optimistic, Most Likely, and Pessimistic.
The relevant financial parameters and projections for both projects over a 4-year economic life are detailed in the following table:
| Project Parameter / Economic State | Project Utkal | Project Hirakud |
| :--- | :--- | :--- |
| Initial Outlay (INR Lakhs) | 500.00 | 500.00 |
| Salvage Value at t=4 (INR Lakhs) | 50.00 | 80.00 |
| **Optimistic State (Probability = 0.25)** | | |
| Annual Cash Inflow (INR Lakhs) | 220.00 | 250.00 |
| Risk-Adjusted Discount Rate | 14.0% | 16.0% |
| **Most Likely State (Probability = 0.55)** | | |
| Annual Cash Inflow (INR Lakhs) | 160.00 | 170.00 |
| Risk-Adjusted Discount Rate | 12.0% | 14.0% |
| **Most Pessimistic State (Probability = 0.20)** | | |
| Annual Cash Inflow (INR Lakhs) | 90.00 | 70.00 |
| Risk-Adjusted Discount Rate | 10.0% | 12.0% |
Additional corporate tax rate applicable to Kalinga Steels & Alloys Ltd is 25%, and depreciation is claimed on a Straight-Line Basis for tax purposes (assume depreciation is non-cash and added back to compute net operating cash flows, whereas initial outlay includes capital equipment and working capital components). The company's corporate cost of capital is 11.5%.
You are required to:
1. Compute the Expected Net Present Value (ENPV) for both Project Utkal and Project Hirakud across all economic states.
2. Determine the Standard Deviation and Coefficient of Variation of NPV for each project to assess relative risk.
3. Recommend the optimal project based on risk-return trade-offs under strategic financial management principles.
🔒 Official Model Solution
Model answers and self-evaluation solutions are available in the Premium Tier & Rankers Plan.
Question 3: PRACTICAL COMPUTATION: Advanced multi-scenario on EVALUATION OF RISKY PROPOSALS FOR INVESTMENT DECISIONS (Part 3)
10 Marks
📌 Evaluated in accordance with Ind AS 36, Income-tax Act, 1961 Section 32, and CAS guidelines.
Kalinga Steels & Alloys Ltd is evaluating an advanced manufacturing expansion project requiring an initial capital outlay of INR 180 crores. The project has a useful life of 4 years with no salvage value. Due to volatile macroeconomic conditions and shifting global commodity tariffs, the Chief Financial Officer has projected three distinct economic scenarios: Optimistic, Most Likely, and Pessimistic, along with their respective probabilities. The company applies a risk-adjusted discount rate methodology. The corporate tax rate applicable is 25 percent plus a 10 percent surcharge and 4 percent Health and Education Cess, resulting in an effective tax rate of 28.846 percent. Depreciation is calculated on a straight-line basis for accounting purposes, and under the Income-tax Act, 1961, the block of assets attracts a Written Down Value (WDV) depreciation rate of 15 percent. The cost of capital (hurdle rate) is 14 percent. The forecasted cash flows before tax across the scenarios are detailed in the following table. You are required to evaluate the risky proposal using the Certainty Equivalent (CE) approach and the Risk-Adjusted Discount Rate (RADR) approach, compute the Expected Net Present Value (ENPV) under both methods, and advise the Board of Directors on the final investment decision under the provisions of the Companies Act, 2013 and strategic financial management principles.
🔒 Official Model Solution
Model answers and self-evaluation solutions are available in the Premium Tier & Rankers Plan.
Question 4: PRACTICAL COMPUTATION: Advanced multi-scenario on EVALUATION OF RISKY PROPOSALS FOR INVESTMENT DECISIONS (Part 4)
10 Marks
📌 Evaluated in accordance with Ind AS 36 (Impairment of Assets) and Guidance Note on Capital Budgeting issued by ICAI/ICMAI.
Kalinga Steels & Alloys Ltd is evaluating an advanced, high-risk capital expenditure project titled 'Project Vajra' involving automated robotic extrusion lines for specialized defense-grade alloy manufacturing. The initial capital outlay required at t = 0 is INR 4,50,00,000, which includes heavy machinery, foundation works, and specialized software licenses. The project has an economic life of 4 years with negligible scrap value. Due to high technological obsolescence and volatile global raw material prices (nickel and titanium), the project cash flows exhibit high uncertainty. Management has formulated three discrete economic scenarios (Boom, Normal, and Recession) with respective subjective probabilities. Furthermore, the company applies a risk-adjusted discount rate methodology alongside certainty equivalent coefficients to evaluate risky proposals under strategic financial management.
The detailed operational and financial forecasts for Project Vajra are presented in the table below:
| Economic Scenario | Probability (P_s) | Year 1 CFAT (INR) | Year 2 CFAT (INR) | Year 3 CFAT (INR) | Year 4 CFAT (INR) |
|-------------------|-------------------|-------------------|-------------------|-------------------|-------------------|
| Boom | 0.30 | 1,80,00,000 | 2,10,00,000 | 2,50,00,000 | 2,80,00,000 |
| Normal | 0.50 | 1,20,00,000 | 1,40,00,000 | 1,60,00,000 | 1,80,00,000 |
| Recession | 0.20 | 60,00,000 | 70,00,000 | 80,00,000 | 90,00,000 |
Additional Financial Parameters:
1. Risk-Free Rate (Rf): 7.00% per annum.
2. Market Risk Premium: 6.50% per annum.
3. Project Beta (beta_p): 1.45 (reflecting high operational leverage and market sensitivity).
4. Corporate Tax Rate: 25.00% plus applicable surcharge and cess, resulting in an effective tax rate of 25.22% (assumed for tax shield computations under Income-tax Act, 1961).
5. Depreciation Method: Straight-Line Method (SLM) over 4 years for tax purposes under Section 32 of the Income-tax Act, 1961, without any additional depreciation.
6. Certainty Equivalent (CE) Coefficients for the respective years to deflate expected cash flows are given as follows: CE_1 = 0.90, CE_2 = 0.80, CE_3 = 0.70, CE_4 = 0.60.
You are required as the Chief Senior Examiner to compute:
(a) The Risk-Adjusted Discount Rate (RADR) using the Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM).
(b) The Expected Net Present Value (ENPV) using the RADR approach.
(c) The Certainty Equivalent Net Present Value (CENPV) using the Certainty Equivalent approach (discounted at the Risk-Free Rate).
(d) A comparative strategic evaluation and final investment decision recommendation under both risk-adjustment methodologies in compliance with ICMAI standards and corporate governance norms.
🔒 Official Model Solution
Model answers and self-evaluation solutions are available in the Premium Tier & Rankers Plan.
Question 5: PRACTICAL COMPUTATION: Advanced multi-scenario on EVALUATION OF RISKY PROPOSALS FOR INVESTMENT DECISIONS (Part 5)
10 Marks
📌 Applicable corporate tax rate 25.168% inclusive of surcharge and cess under Income-tax Act 1961, adhering to Ind AS 36 and CAS 17 standards.
Vardhaman Synthetics Ltd is evaluating a high-risk capital expenditure proposal for setting up an advanced specialty polymer manufacturing plant at Dahej, Gujarat. The project requires an initial capital outlay of INR 12,000 Lakhs towards plant and machinery, with an additional working capital requirement of INR 2,000 Lakhs at Year 0. The plant has a useful life of 4 years with no salvage value. The firm follows the Straight Line Method of depreciation for income tax purposes, and the applicable corporate tax rate is 25% (plus applicable surcharge and cess, taken effectively at 25.168%). Due to technological obsolescence and volatile global crude oil prices, the project cash flows are subject to high uncertainty. The finance team has established three operational scenarios—Optimistic, Most Likely, and Pessimistic—with respective probabilities of 0.25, 0.50, and 0.25. The project's risk-free rate is 6.5%, the market risk premium is 7.5%, and the project's equity beta under the asset-risk matching approach is evaluated at 1.45. The company maintains a target capital structure of 60% equity and 40% debt, with a pre-tax cost of debt of 9.5%. You are required to: (a) Compute the Risk-Adjusted Discount Rate (RADR) using the Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM) and weighted average cost framework. (b) Calculate the expected Net Present Value (NPV) under the multi-scenario probabilistic distribution. (c) Determine the certainty equivalent cash flows and certainty equivalent net present value assuming certainty equivalent coefficients for Years 1 to 4 are 0.95, 0.90, 0.85, and 0.80 respectively. (d) Provide a strategic financial recommendation aligned with ICMAI evaluation standards and relevant Cost Accounting Standards (CAS). Below is the scenario data:
| Particulars | Year 1 | Year 2 | Year 3 | Year 4 |
| :--- | :--- | :--- | :--- | :--- |
| Optimistic Cash Inflow after Tax (INR Lakhs) | 5,500 | 6,200 | 7,000 | 7,500 |
| Most Likely Cash Inflow after Tax (INR Lakhs) | 4,200 | 4,800 | 5,300 | 5,800 |
| Pessimistic Cash Inflow after Tax (INR Lakhs) | 3,000 | 3,300 | 3,600 | 4,000 |
🔒 Official Model Solution
Model answers and self-evaluation solutions are available in the Premium Tier & Rankers Plan.
Advertisement