Ch 3: ECONOMIC EFFICIENCY OF THE FIRM – PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS — Previous Year Exam Questions (PYQ)
Final
📚 Strategic Performance Management & Business Valuation
📖 Ch.3 — ECONOMIC EFFICIENCY OF THE FIRM – PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS
⭐ V1: Previous Year Question (PYQ)
⚡ Free Mode (Answers Locked)
⏱ Duration: 54 Mins
🎯 Total Marks: 30
Passed at: 12 Marks
Max Attempts: 10
⚖️ Statutory Applicability: AY 2026-27 & Current Institute Curriculum
Answer ALL questions. Working notes / statutory sections must form part of the answers.
📑 Exam Questions
6 Questions • Total 30 Marks1(a): Profit Optimization under different Market Structure
5 Marks
12.0
15.0
C
R
2.2
14.5
20.0
D
S
0.9
8.5
14.0
E
T
2.5
11.0
22.0
Average
1.7
11.0
17.6
Particulars
EBITDA Multiple
Sales Multiple
Earnings Multiple
EBITDA
Revenue
EPS
Reported Value
125.0
700.0
0.9
Value Multiplier
11.0
1.7
17.6
Enterprise Value
1,375.0
1,162.0
Less: Debt
500.0
500.0
Equity Value
875.0
662.0
No. of Shares
Value per Share
17.5
13.2
15.8
Current Price per share
11.00
11.00
*Premium over Current Price
59%
20%
44%
7. (b)
Working Note : Computation of Pre-Merger EPS
Formula : EPS = Earnings After Tax (EAT) ÷ Number of equity shares
Particulars
Horizon Enterprises (Acquirer)
Vertex Solutions (Target)
Earnings After Tax (₹)
1,20,00,000
36,00,000
Number of Equity Shares
15,00,000
3,00,000
Pre-merger EPS (₹)
8.00
12.00
Market Value per Share (MPS) (₹)
240.00
180.00
(i)
Post-merger EPS if the exchange ratio is based on current market price
Calculation of Exchange Ratio (ER)
- Exchange Ratio = MPS of Target Company ÷ MPS of Acquiring Company
- Exchange Ratio = ₹ 180 ÷ ₹ 240 = 0.75 : 1
- (Horizon Enterprises Ltd. will issue 0.75 shares for every 1 share of Vertex Solutions Ltd.)
Computation of Post-Merger EPS
Particulars
Value
Combined Earnings (₹ 1,20,00,000 + ₹ 36,00,000) (₹)
1,56,00,000
Horizon's existing shares
15,00,000
New shares issued to Vertex (3,00,000 × 0.75)
2,25,000
Total Post-Merger Shares
17,25,000
Post-Merger EPS (₹ 1,56,00,000 ÷ 17,25,000) (₹)
9.04
(ii)
Exchange ratio to ensure no earnings dilution for Vertex Solutions Ltd.
For Vertex Solutions Ltd.'s shareholders to suffer absolutely no dilution in their earnings, their
equivalent post-merger EPS must be strictly equal to their pre-merger EPS of ₹ 12.00.
Method 1 : EPS Ratio Method
To maintain identical earnings per share for the target company, the maximum exchange ratio is derived
using the respective pre-merger Earnings Per Share of both companies.
- Exchange Ratio = EPS of Target Company ÷ EPS of Acquiring Company
- Exchange Ratio = ₹ 12.00 ÷ ₹ 8.00 = 1.50 : 1
Alternative :
Method 2 :
- Let the required Exchange Ratio be 'ER'.
- Target’s Equivalent EPS = Post-Merger EPS × ER
- Target’s Equivalent EPS = [Combined EAT ÷ (Horizon's Shares + New Shares)] × ER
- 12.00 = [1,56,00,000 ÷ (15,00,000 + 3,00,000 × ER)] × ER
- 12.00 × (15,00,000 + 3,00,000 ER) = 1,56,00,000 ER
- 1,80,00,000 + 36,00,000 ER = 1,56,00,000 ER
- 1,56,00,000 ER - 36,00,000 ER = 1,80,00,000
- 1,20,00,000 ER = 1,80,00,000
- ER = 1,80,00,000 ÷ 1,20,00,000 = 1.50
- Exchange Ratio = 1.50 : 1
The Post Merger EPS will be
(
)
1.5
x
300000
1500000
÷
15600000
+
(15600000 ÷ 1950000) = ₹ 8.00.
The earnings of Vertex Solutions shareholder Post Merger will be (450,000 shares × ₹ 8.00) i.e. ₹ 36,00,000
which will be maintained & not diminished by merger.
Conclusion :
Horizon Enterprises Ltd. must offer an exchange ratio of 1.50 shares for every 1 share of Vertex Solutions
Ltd. to ensure that the target's shareholders face zero dilution in their available earnings.
8. (a)
(i)
Year-over-Year Trend Analysis:
(₹ in lakhs)
2022
2023
2024
YOY Change (22-
23) (%)
YOY Change (23-24)
(%)
Revenue
12000
13500
14400
12.5
6.67
EBIT
1800
1800
1200
-33.33
Net Profit
1600
1550
-3.13
-41.94
Gross Profit
4200
4500
4200
7.14
-6.67
Operating Expenses
2400
2700
3000
12.5
11.11
Key Observations:
- Revenue is growing but growth rate is slowing down.
- EBIT remains flat from 2022 to Year 2023 but drops sharply in 2024 (-33%).
- Net profit declines, especially in 2024, reflecting margin pressures.
- Operating expenses are increasing consistently.
- Gross profit increased in 2023 but decreased in 2024 indicating margin pressure from rising COGS.
(ii)
Financial Viability of ₹ 1500 lakhs Automation Investment:
Assuming revenue growth continues at 6.67% from 2024 to 2025, revenue in 2025 = 14400 X 1.0667
= ₹ 15360 lakhs
Current net profit margin = 6.25 % (in 2024) (900 / 14400)
If improved by 4%, the new margin is 10.25%.
Now net profit for 2025 = 10.25 % X ₹15360 = ₹ 1574.4 lakhs
Old Net Profit for 2025 = 6.25 % X ₹15360 = ₹ 960 lakhs
Incremental profit due to automation = ₹ 1574.4 -₹960 = ₹ 614.40 lakhs.
NPV of the investment = ₹ 614.40 X 3.605 - ₹ 1500 = ₹ 714.91 lakhs.
Decision :
Since NPV is positive, the automation project is financially viable and should be accepted.
Alternative Answer :
(ii) Financial Viability of ₹ 1500 Lakhs Automation Investment :
Since no future revenue forecast has been provided in the question, the latest available revenue (2024)
is considered for evaluating the benefit of automation.
Automation is expected to improve profit margin by 4 %
Annual Benefit = ₹ 14400 x 4 % = ₹ 576 Lakh
PV Factor (12 %, 5 years) = 3.605
PV = ₹ 576 x 3.605 = ₹ 2076.48 Lakh
Net Present Value (NPV)
NPV = ₹ 2076.48 – ₹ 1500 = ₹576.48 Lakh
Decision :
Since NPV is positive, the automation project is financially viable and should be accepted.
8. (b)
The current market value of shares of RIL is ₹20,00,000 & SIL is ₹10,00,000
Scheme I : Issue of 20,000 shares of RIL
Particulars
RIL
SIL
Total
No. of shares
50,000
20,000
70,000
EPS
5 (3,50,000 /70,000)
Market price(₹)
Market value (₹)
25,00,000
10,00,000
35,00,000
Gain / (Loss) (₹)
5,00,000
Nil
5,00,000
Inference : Entire gain accrues to RIL shareholders.
Scheme II : Issue of 25,000 shares of RIL
Particulars
RIL
SIL
Total
No. of shares
50,000
25,000
75,000
EPS
4.6666 (3,50,000 / 75,000)
Market price (₹)
46.667
Market value (₹)
23,33,333
11,66,667
35,00,000
Gain / (Loss) (₹)
3,33,333
1,66,667
5,00,000
Inference: Both RIL and SIL shareholders benefit.
Scheme III : Issue of 30,000 shares of RIL
Particulars
RIL
SIL
Total
No. of shares
50,000
30,000
80,000
EPS
4.375 (3,50,000 / 80,000)
Market price (₹)
43.75
Market value (₹)
21,87,500
13,12,500
35,00,000
Gain / (Loss) (₹)
1,87,500
3,12,500
5,00,000
Inference : SIL shareholders gain at the expense of RIL shareholders.
Conclusion:
Since both set of shareholders gain, issue of 25,000 shares is recommended as that will be fair to shareholder
of both companies & will be most acceptable.
--------------------------------------------------
🔒 Official Model Solution
Model answers and self-evaluation solutions are available in the Premium Tier & Rankers Plan.
1(b): Economic Performance Indicator
5 Marks
In view of increasing cost of operating own fleet of cars, Krish Ltd., is presently
considering two proposals viz.,
(i)
To hire cars with drivers from an agency @ ₹ 800 per car per month. The
company will bear the cost of petrol, oil and tyres.
(ii) The executive will be given ₹ 25,000 interest-free loan repayable in 5 years to
buy his own car. The company will, however, provide him free petrol and ₹ 500
per month for maintenance and driver's wages.
If the present cost of a car is ₹ 50,000 and monthly average running is 2,000
kilometers, find out the most economic way with the help of the following data:
Paise per km.
Petrol
Oil
Tyre
Repair
Tax and Insurance
₹ 560/year
Driver's wages and Bonus
₹ 720/month
Life of a car
5 years
Resale value at the end of 5th year
₹ 10,000
Assume Interest @ 18% per annum
🔒 Official Model Solution
Model answers and self-evaluation solutions are available in the Premium Tier & Rankers Plan.
2(a): Economic Performance Indicator
5 Marks
The cost (c) of a firm is given by the function C = 4x3 + 9x2 + 11x + 27. Find the Average
Cost, Marginal Cost, Average Variable Cost and the Average Fixed Cost, ‘x' being the
output.
🔒 Official Model Solution
Model answers and self-evaluation solutions are available in the Premium Tier & Rankers Plan.
2(b): Economic Performance Indicator
5 Marks
0.869
(8.69)
0.756
3.78
0.6575
6.575
0.572
8.58
0.497
9.94
Total sum of present value =
20.185
Terminal Value t = Cash Flowt+1 / r-gstable
Cash flow t+1 = Cash flow (1+g) = 20 (1+0.05) = 21 Lakhs
Terminal Value = 21/(0.08-0.05) = ₹ 700 Lakhs.
Present value of terminal value = 700 x 0.497 = ₹ 347.9
Value of the firm = Total sum of present value + Present value of terminal value
= ₹ 20.185 + ₹ 347.9 = ₹ 368.085.
🔒 Official Model Solution
Model answers and self-evaluation solutions are available in the Premium Tier & Rankers Plan.
3(a): Profit Optimization under different Market Structure
5 Marks
A company has a capital base of ₹ 1 crore and has a earned profits to the tune of
₹ 11,00,000. The Return on Investment (ROI) of the particular industry to which the
company belongs is 12.5%. If acquired by a company, it is expected that the profits
will increase by ₹ 2,50,000 over and above the target profit. Determine the amount
of maximum bid price for that particular executive and the maximum salary that
could be offered to him.
🔒 Official Model Solution
Model answers and self-evaluation solutions are available in the Premium Tier & Rankers Plan.
3(b): Profit Optimization under different Market Structure
5 Marks
(i)
The number of shares to be issued by Q Ltd.:
The Exchange ratio is 0.5
So, the new shares = 1,80,000 × 0.5 = 90,000 shares.
(ii)
EPS of Q Ltd., after acquisition:
Total Earnings = ₹ (18,00,000 + 3,60,000)
₹ 21,60,000
No. of Shares (6,00,000 + 90,000)
6,90,000
EPS (₹ 21,60,000) / 6,90,000
₹ 3.13
(iii) Equivalent EPS of R Ltd.,
No. of new shares
0.5
EPS(₹)
3.13
Equivalent (3.13 ×0.5) (₹)
1.57
(iv) New Market price of Q Ltd., (P/E remaining unchanged):
Present P/E Ratio of Q Ltd.,
10 times
Expected EPS after merger (₹)
3.13
Expected Market Price (3.13 × 10) (₹)
31.30
(v) Market Value of merged firm:
Total number of Shares
6,90,000
Expected Market Price (₹)
31.30
Total Value (6,90,000 x 31.30) (₹)
2,15,97,000
🔒 Official Model Solution
Model answers and self-evaluation solutions are available in the Premium Tier & Rankers Plan.
Advertisement